Plan Your Heart’s Delight, Round 2

Is it your year to put on the romance? To spice it up? To keep it smokin’ hot? We’ve updated our list, so you can keep putting on the charm. We aren’t and don’t claim to be relationship therapists, but we do think we can give you a hand with starting the night off right: follow the golden night-of-romance rule (the one the guy just might break), and make reservations for Valentine’s Day.
Here are some of our no-fail favorites in no particular order:
1. Fresco, 1513 S. 1500 East, Salt Lake City, (801) 486-1300. This little place, and by little we mean tiny, is the most cute and quaint spot in Salt Lake City. We love the quiet conversations and candlelight. And did we mention that the food is good? Call soon, we hear it fills up very quickly.
2. Lugano, 3364 E. 2300 South, Salt Lake City, (801) 412-9994. Big on ambiance and good service, this conveniently-located cottage serves authentic Italian. Share a plate of focaccia (with fresh basil-infused parmesan shreds) and polish it off with a tasty dessert.
3. Silver Fork Lodge, Big Cottonwood Canyon, (801) 533-9977. Resting in a scenic canyon valley, the dining room features a top-rate menu and a cozy fireplace. Order the Canyon Pepper Steak and start and/or finish off with homemade cinnamon rolls.
4. Snake Creek Grill, 650 W. 100 South, Heber, (435) 654-2133. Make a night of it and head to Wasatch County, where, behind an old-town facade, sits Salt Lake Magazine’s “Best American Regional Cuisine 2006.” It’s Zagat-rated, too. Start off with Crisp Corn Cakes with Sweet Pepper Cream. The ribs are unbeatable, too.
5. Melting Pot, 340 S. Main St., Salt Lake City, (801) 521-6358. There’s nothing like an open flame to turn up the heat. Pop in for a teamwork dinner or simply a do-it-yourself dessert.
6. Cafe Terigo, 424 Main St., Park City, (435) 645-9555. Alpine location, delicious menu, quaint atmosphere. Do not leave without sharing the bread pudding.
7. Cafe Trio, 680 S. 900 East, Salt Lake City, (801) 533-8746 and 6405 S. 3000 East, Cottonwood Heights, (801) 944-8756. Though it’s a little safe, it’s still a little special with a dessert menu that includes Toll House Pie. Yes, please.
8. Cinegrill, 344 S. 300 East, Salt Lake City, (801) 328-4900. This joint is special in a your-grandma’s-favorite-restaurant kind of way. Though we’re never quite sure what to order or if it will be memorable, we love how we feel like we’re in the 1940s upon entering the place, with its mirrored walls and checkered floor, and especially if someone’s tickling the ivory with a little jazz number.
9. Market Street Broiler, 260 S. 1300 East, Salt Lake City, (801) 583-8808. Eye-pleasing architecture and a coastal menu are the hallmarks of this Salt Lake City classic. An oldie but a goodie, we keep going back. If it’s full, try one of the Market Street Grills.
10. Epic, 707 Fort Union, Midvale, (801) 748-1300. Tasty appetizers and upscale entrees with reasonable prices. Though not as private, we love the warm atmosphere, especially a not-at-all annoying and actually-welcome guitar player who swoons patrons with covers of ’80s and ’90s love songs fit for FM 100. Try the lemon mascarpone cheesecake to finish off.
11. Michelangelo Ristorante, 2156 S. Highland Drive, Salt Lake City, (801) 466-0961. With a uniquely un-American collection of dishes, this little Italian gem has been a treat to Sugar House residents for years. It’s small too, so it’s best to call early.
12. Tuscany, 2832 E. 6200 South, Holladay, (801) 277-9919. Despite it size and popularity, Tuscany is full of appeal and charm––and includes a full-service valet; ideal for a cold night.
13. Tiburon, 8256 S. 700 East, Sandy, (801) 255-1200. Try the lobster or crabcakes as an appetizer, then step it up with lamb tenderloin. For dessert, you can enjoy creme brulee. Yum.
14. Pine, 4760 S. 900 East, Salt Lake City, (801) 288-2211. Voted Best New Restaurant in 2007 by Salt Lake Magazine, this south-city hub is packed with flavor: Uinta Hefeweizen-steamed Penn Cove Mussels with fennel shallot butter and grilled salmon….
15. The Boulevard, 2335 Murray Holladay Boulevard, Holladay, (801) 274-6999. Quaint, romantic and packed with character, this Holladay star serves up Guava Lemon Scallops and Kurobuta Pork Tenderloin.
Before you put it in ink, ask the reservation-taker what the Valentine’s Day menu will look like. You don’t want to be disappointed when your significant other’s treasured lobster bisque isn’t on the three-item menu.
Or, if you want to try something nice, easy and stay-at-homey, you can drop by Papa Murphy’s on the way home from the office and pick up a heart-shaped pizza to cook in your very own oven. Stop by the store to pick up some fresh veggies for toppings, and maybe a little bubbly, or just some bubble bath.
Any other suggestions?






January 30th, 2008 at 10:30 am
There is a great restaurant in Utah County (off of state street on the border of Orem/Provo) called Chef’s Table that is extremely romantic with candles, music, etc. Perfect Valentines dinner!
January 30th, 2008 at 10:41 am
No Bambara?!? Top notch food with service to boot. Perfect for a romantic night. Heck finish the meal with a cocktail or two in the adjacent bar then retire to a luxurious room in the Hotel Monaco for the night.
They used to have a romance package option as well…
January 30th, 2008 at 11:25 am
I feel torn. You’ve given away some of my hidden-gem favorites and given me some tips on places I’ve never heard of, but must try. Thanks for the killer list. But if Cinegrill is overbooked, I blame you, YHO :)
January 30th, 2008 at 11:41 am
My fav new place is café niche on 300 so. and 800 e. I don’t know if they’ll be having a v-day celebration but any friday or saturday night it’s a fun romantic little place to spend the evening and yummy food to boot.
January 30th, 2008 at 2:24 pm
Holy YHO-moley! You’ve left no stone unturned. Thank you thank you thank you.
January 31st, 2008 at 2:29 pm
When at Cinegrill you must order the Corned Beef Sandwich. It’s their specialty and, I think, the best thing on the menu.
January 31st, 2008 at 11:54 pm
I think another option would be to try Sages! I enjoyed a lovely evening last V-day and love the atmosphere and food. They had a three meal option, so a call in advance might be wise just in case you wanted or expected something else! It has awesome food!
February 3rd, 2008 at 8:15 pm
Faustina! It’s just so good. I love the molten chocolate lava cake and everything else is so scrumdiddlyumptious, too. It’s across the street from Sages cafe on 300 south btwn 400 east and 500 east
February 19th, 2010 at 9:33 am
With thanks!! Yet one more useful contribution, surely why I come for your blogs constantly!!